Excellent Service
Excellent service! Customer support was quick to address my problem and provide quick easy solutions while maintaining a professional and friendly manner
Slink Mink
Was this helpful?
Alter Sleeves
4.950 reviews
Last reviewed: Dec 11, 2024Do you agree with Alter Sleeves's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 54 customers have already said.
www.altersleeves.comMember since Mar 2026
Alter Sleeves is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed December 11, 2024.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
50 reviews
Great product, AMAZING customer service!
The sleeves look awesome! The quality is great, and the customer support is AMAZING! Their support team went above and beyond to make sure that my order got to me after some shipping issues. Would absolutely recommend shopping from them!
Gunnar
Was this helpful?
Lost shipping.
I sent an email this morning and they responded in just a couple hour. Apparently my shipping got lost somewhere so they will send a new one. Thank you Dylan!
Daniele Pinetto
Was this helpful?
I contacted customer support about sleeve misalignment.
I contacted customer support about some sleeves that had an alignment issue. I had intended to purchase replacements if they were available, but after seeing images of the sleeves I had I was given a replacement free of charge! Very happy with the help received!
Johnny Lamb
Was this helpful?
Great service and fast response
Great service and fast response
Lily
Was this helpful?
Good service!
Quick reply and concise, to-the-point assistance. Thank you!
Stephan Matthee
Was this helpful?
Very Helpful
Quick response time, communicative, and very helpful in solving the issues I was having.
Nicholas L.
Was this helpful?
Quick response
Quick response from Alter Sleeves' staff with a straightforward solution to my problem. Pleased with the experience.
Lucas Fabbro
Was this helpful?
Quick response after my initial email
Quick response after my initial email. Dylan was able to answer my question, and cancel my order without delay. First customer service interaction with Mythic Gaming / Alter Sleeves and it was a good one. Thanks.
Matt Sprague
Was this helpful?
They’re so helpful and very quick to…
They’re so helpful and very quick to respond in the case of missing items. Love the alter sleeves definitely coming back for more!
Coleman Murphy
Was this helpful?
AlterSleeves and Targa F N Rock!!
I ordered two sets of sleeves. The first package arrived but the second got lost. Targa as AlterSleeves went above and beyond in terms of customer service. They are literally the best customer service people in any business. And the product! Omg, Ricky Thomas designed Door of Destinies hello! Absolutely superb and just fit perfectly over the card.
Benjamin
Was this helpful?
A MAGIC experience.
It was a very pleasant experience. Very swift response and my issue was taken care of no questions asked. AMAZING!!!
Kaleb Littlejohn
Was this helpful?
Really Fast Response!
Really Fast Response!
Jorge Ortiz
Was this helpful?
they have been very helpful
they have been very helpful
Robert Knight
Was this helpful?
Had a small issue with the product and…
Had a small issue with the product and reported it and they replaced all of the product for free even those without an issue.
Dayton Heffelfinger
Was this helpful?
Fast and eficent (D
Fast and eficent (D. Justino)Ty
Dani Rey
Was this helpful?
Very responsive aftersales team
Got into a confusing situation but the aftersales team was great.Everything got fixed in about an hour.
Jerome Floerke
Was this helpful?
Awesome Customer Service
There was a slight mistake in my order however the team at Alter Sleeves rectified it superbly by offering me an amazing promo code on my next order! This is why I come back!
MinimanXC _
Was this helpful?
Great company
Great company! Supports MtG content creators and stands behind their product. One of my sleeves was dominantly white, and as such the card behind showed through; they offered me an exchange or refund- that's good customer service.
BtRB_Ver
Was this helpful?
Dylan, This One's For You!
I emailed support about the status of my order. I knew about a delay but didn't hear anything for weeks after that announcement.Dylan answered my support request and explained the situation, to which I totally understood; case closed.Now here's where it gets good.A week later, Dylan emails me-they just packaged my order and shipped it. I was like, "Dang! I didn't ask for this..." But you know what? I super appreciated it. The gesture goes far beyond my expectations for customer service and is nothing short of exemplary. Dylan, I hope your manager reads this and gives props where they're due.Thank you for your help! Stay safe out there and take care.
Ray Bugayong
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Alter Sleeves has a 4.9/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of April 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/altersleeves-com