Great day of fishing
Great day of fishing. The captain and mate were friendly and worked hard to make sure we caught fish. The $10 lunches were well worth it.
Nicholas Newman
Was this helpful?
Fish Key West®
4.920 reviews
Last reviewed: Dec 14, 2025Do you agree with Fish Key West®'s TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 20 customers have already said.
www.fishkeywest.comMember since Mar 2026
Fish Key West® is an online company. Based on 20 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed December 14, 2025.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
20 reviews
Great captain and crew
Great captain and crew , weather was perfect and plenty of fish.
Charles Cox
Was this helpful?
Guys were great fishing was fun!!!!
Guys were great fishing was fun!!!!
Farrah Lynn Phipps
Was this helpful?
boat and crew were awesome
boat and crew were awesome. Only negative is that Fish Key West did not notify the boast charter that two of our party had cancelled. Prevented the boat from fulfilling those two spots
Michael Garrison
Was this helpful?
A fun half-day of fishing
Lots of room to fish on board. Mate and captain were knowledgeable and helpful. They put us on the fish right away and there were plenty of fish to go around. We caught primarily grunt with a few grouper, yellowtail and a parrotfish thrown in. This is an older vessel with few amenities but, for a four-hour trip, she gets the job done. If you are looking for a short fishing trip while in Key West, I would recommend this one.
William Parker
Was this helpful?
Great Experience!
Great experience! Boat in great shape and crew performed admirably. Fun day of fishing for the first time deep sea fishing in Key West. I’ll be back soon!!!
Jon Robbins
Was this helpful?
The trip was great
The trip was great. The captain and mate worked very hard and everyone on the boat landed a fish.
Scott G.
Was this helpful?
Fun Day
The captain sorry forgot her name was awesome bubbly and just fun. Hermate was extremely attentive. Thanks for fun day on the water
Carl
Was this helpful?
Good crew and equipment.
Good crew and equipment.
Ken K
Was this helpful?
You helped book a wonderful trip
You helped book a wonderful trip
David Farmer
Was this helpful?
Amazing Customer Experience!!!
Amazing Customer Experience!!!
Mike
Was this helpful?
Great
Great! Came home with fish!
Felix Jackson
Was this helpful?
We had a great time
We had a great time. Awesome Captain, great fishing, great time, tons of energy. Highly recommend
Matt Stamler
Was this helpful?
Conch Too was great
Conch Too was great. Professional and the 5 fishermen each caught multiple fish. The cleaned and fileted the fish. We took our catch to Dante’s that evening and took advantage of the Hook and Cook. It was an amazing experience for my son and me.
Michael Yonnotti
Was this helpful?
The skipper was great!
The skipper was great!
Frank Ray
Was this helpful?
We had a amazing time,we caught so many…
We had a amazing time,we caught so many fish, we caught 12 mahi-mahi,and a Bonita. ALL three of the mahi I caught were so big,that my shoulders were hurting reeling them in. I think the mate was Ross and the capn was Gary,I think not sure. Both of them were so very knowledgeable and very professional. Taking care of buissiness and taking us where we caught the amazing amount we did. Will definitely be back.
scott friedman
Was this helpful?
Great crew and captain
Great crew and captain. 2nd year and will definitely book again for next year
Mike Howe
Was this helpful?
Successful trip.
The troll bite just wasn't there, so the captain and mate took us in closer and we caught huge mutton snapper and red grouper.The air conditioned cabin was very comfortable. I will book again next April in 2025.
Tom from Georgia
Was this helpful?
Best Crew in Key West
The Blind Squirrel was accommodating, clean, tackle was available, guides were very helpful, and the fishing knowledge was superior. We were on the fish within 30 minutes of getting out to the reef.
Mario Contreras
Was this helpful?
Easy
Easy, convenient, just double check your email and phone#.
Marc
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Fish Key West® has a 4.9/5 rating based on 20 verified reviews as of April 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/fishkeywest-com