This is the place to get Medigap Insurance.
Just got Medigap insurance for my husband. R.W. was my agent. He was helpful, knowledgeable and had a sense of humor so it was nice to do business with him.
Susan Scott
Was this helpful?
Medigap by MedSuppGuide Reviews
4.933 reviews
Last reviewed: Nov 20, 2020Do you agree with Medigap by MedSuppGuide Reviews's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 34 customers have already said.
medsuppguide.comMember since Mar 2026
Medigap by MedSuppGuide Reviews is an online company. Based on 33 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed November 20, 2020.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
33 reviews
I have tested many waters as I…
I have tested many waters as I approached retirement age and Medicare supplement insurance. Much to ponder and decide upon. I finally settled on Melanie Coney of IAC and Heartland. Well informed. A PRO! Very pleasant as well. Its who I purchased my Plan G from.John Mageras
customer
Was this helpful?
Agent was very thorough and extremely…
Agent was very thorough and extremely helpful.
customer
Was this helpful?
A great experience from start to finish…
A great experience from start to finish —- people were helpful, able to answer all my questions and to guide me quickly and expertly to exactly what I needed .
Karen Smith
Was this helpful?
Thank You Stephanie... a lot!
Amazingly, my wife and I have reached that age. How we got here is a blur, but nonetheless we arrived at the age for Medicare. We realized that choosing the right Medicare policy would be important. We also realized that choosing that policy was confusing and concerning. We went to a volunteer Medicare “expert” adviser at our local area agency on aging. This was worse than useless. In fact my wife and I left more confused. We researched Medicare plans on our own and were hesitant to decide, when happily Stephanie Baldwin from the Heartland Financial Group called out-of-the -blue and exactly at the right time. We spoke by phone, emailed and finally made a decision over a no pressure few weeks of conversations. Now, we are about to discuss which drug plan will work best for us. In Stephanie We Trust.
Mike Glazer
Was this helpful?
Very helpful
Very helpful. Answered all my questions. Was kind and patient when explaining the difference plans.
Charles Dinwiddie
Was this helpful?
Derek was SUPER helpful
Derek was SUPER helpful, quick and efficient!
customer
Was this helpful?
I did a lot of research on Medicare…
I did a lot of research on Medicare Supplement Insurance before calling insurance companies. I was fortunate to get connected to this company and Chance Roberts. He answered my questions and helped me select a plan to suit my needs from the insurance company offering the best rate with an extra plus of having a high financial stability rating. No high pressure sales tactics. Just the facts. After agonizing over this decision, I feel as if a great weight has been lifted.
customer M Lewis
Was this helpful?
Andrea went through a couple of…
Andrea went through a couple of insurance plans that were beneficial to us.He is great to work with and goes over and above to help you find the right plan.
susan
Was this helpful?
Really helped me navigate the confusing…
Really helped me navigate the confusing world of 'supplements' andhelped me get a great plan immediately!
Susan M.
Was this helpful?
Hard to understand for me but received…
Hard to understand for me but received very excellent help. Thank you.
customer
Was this helpful?
My agent was very knowledgeable and…
My agent was very knowledgeable and helpful.
Chad Parker
Was this helpful?
Great service
We received great service and our agent, Melanie, was very knowledgeable about dental insurance products. We will use her services again. She found insurance that specifically covered a dentist we wanted to use.
Stuart
Was this helpful?
Stephanie was very caring and helpful
Stephanie was very caring and helpful. My husband and I felt like she was working out things for our best interest. Stephanie was patient and explained things clearly. Great job!
DW
Was this helpful?
Excellence
Trustworthy, professional, answered all of our many questions.
Alice and Bob Brown
Was this helpful?
Love doing business with Andre Santiago
Love doing business with Andre Santiago!! Very knowledgeable and great customer service!! I was not pressured at all!! I continue to talk about what a great help he was... I am glad I am doing business with him!!
Debbie Lardner
Was this helpful?
He gave me all the information I needed.
He gave me all the information I needed.
Janice Logar
Was this helpful?
Great job
Was very helpful very informative
Tresa Dilling
Was this helpful?
I can't thank Joe Waddell enough for …
I can't thank Joe Waddell enough for helping me sign up for my Medicare supplement plan he took the time to explain everything to me and definitely made it easier for me to get the best plan for me and it is affordable
Sandra Vanwinkle
Was this helpful?
I was so pleased with both how …
I was so pleased with both how professional and involved Andre was with the process. Response time was immediate and results were both quick and organized.
mickey
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Medigap by MedSuppGuide Reviews has a 4.9/5 rating based on 33 verified reviews as of April 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/medsuppguide-com