Trust PlaneTrustPlane
St Johns Fragrance logo

St Johns Fragrance

4.750 reviews
Last reviewed: Jul 23, 2023

Do you agree with St Johns Fragrance's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 80 customers have already said.

stjohnsbayrum.comMember since Mar 2026

St Johns Fragrance is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed July 23, 2023.

Customer Reviews

Write a Review
Filter:
50 reviews

Bay YUM!

Ordered Madras & Bay Rum - had some issues putting the order through the check out and was kindly give free shipping by customer services. The shipping from US-UK was stupidly fast and the products were even more high quality than I anticipated. Thank you.

Andy
Was this helpful?

Great product and packaging!

Great product and packaging!

Dan Mansolillo
Was this helpful?

disappointed in the new packaging.

I will say that I am disappointed in the new packaging - i miss that classic, ritzy metal medalion. The new packaging looks like it was designed in High School art class.

Allen Eagles
Was this helpful?

Easy transaction online...Wonderful Bay Rum!

Easy transaction online. Most importantly, St. Johns Bay Rum is a wonderful fragrance: soft, sweet, and enduring. Blends well with body chemistry. My favorite!

Alex Nesterenko
Was this helpful?

My husband loves this scent

My husband loves this scent. The packaging was great. Very island inspired.

Laura
Was this helpful?

Great cologne

Great cologne, on time delivery. Worth the money!

Charles Cobb
Was this helpful?

No issues

No issues! It was shipped I think the same day I ordered, received it pretty quickly in New York. My husband LOVES his Bay Rum so- great all around!! Thank you as always!

Holly
Was this helpful?

Excellent as Always

Beautiful product, fast ship!

The Stouffers
Was this helpful?

St. John's Bay Run is great

I really like St. John's Bay run. My wife really likes it too.

Tom Mason
Was this helpful?

Love the product

Love the product. Only hitch in the giddy-up was delivery but that was on USPS end. Love that you followed up to see I got my order.

Bob Sloan
Was this helpful?

Excellent product the Bay Rum soap…

Excellent product the Bay Rum soap smells fantastic.

Grumpy Gregory
Was this helpful?

Great stuff

I've been using St Johns Bay Rum and West Lime soaps and colognes for years. Wonderful, authentic scents. St Johns always quickly ships and all the items are well packaged.

Downing
Was this helpful?

No complaints

No complaints. Everything went perfectly

sharon peterson
Was this helpful?

I placed my order and in true to life…

I placed my order and in true to life fashion I received my order within five business days. I opened my package and was pleasantly surprised by the fishnet woven bottle. The fragrance is incredible! Even after working out for two hours I continued to smell fresh and clean.

Gregory Hollins
Was this helpful?

Great fragrance!

Great fragrance!

Norma Jean
Was this helpful?

Love the Bay Rum

Love the Bay Rum. It has been a long time since I bought it. the order experience went well. Thanks.

Alice Scamuffo
Was this helpful?

Experience was easy and trouble free

Experience was easy and trouble free. Scent is a little strong but with light use, it has grown on me. No one's fault there. All is well !!

Jim
Was this helpful?

It was a good transaction.

It was a good transaction.

Joel Lebreton
Was this helpful?

Love them both!!

I love the dry down on the bay rum. And, omg the opening on the west indian lime makes me feel like I should be on an island somewhere with my shirt off drinking a margarita..lol

maximus prime
Was this helpful?

Nice fragrance.

Nice fragrance.

Paul
Was this helpful?
Cite this page

According to TrustPlane, St Johns Fragrance has a 4.7/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of April 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/stjohnsbayrum-com