Trust PlaneTrustPlane
S

Shoe Carnival

1.8120 reviews
Last reviewed: Feb 1, 2026
shoecarnival.comMember since Feb 2026

Shoe Carnival is an online company. Based on 120 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 1.8 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed February 1, 2026.

Customer Reviews

Write a Review
Filter:
120 reviews

Item Not Received, Refund Refused

I am extremely disappointed with Shoe Carnival’s handling of my order.I placed order #815152321, was charged in full, and never received the item. Despite this, customer service claims the package was “successfully delivered” and has refused both a refund and a reshipment, offering no meaningful proof of delivery or resolution.I thoroughly checked my address, confirmed with everyone in my household, and contacted neighbors. No package was received. Shoe Carnival’s response was essentially, “It says delivered, so we’re done,” leaving me without merchandise and without my money.This experience feels careless and dismissive of the customer. When a company takes payment but does not ensure the customer actually receives the product—and then refuses to help—that is unacceptable.I am now forced to dispute this charge with my bank and escalate the issue further. I would caution others to be aware that if something goes wrong with delivery, Shoe Carnival may not stand behind their order

Majeedah
Was this helpful?

Item Not Received, Refund Refused

I am extremely disappointed with Shoe Carnival’s handling of my order.I placed order #815152321, was charged in full, and never received the item. Despite this, customer service claims the package was “successfully delivered” and has refused both a refund and a reshipment, offering no meaningful proof of delivery or resolution.I thoroughly checked my address, confirmed with everyone in my household, and contacted neighbors. No package was received. Shoe Carnival’s response was essentially, “It says delivered, so we’re done,” leaving me without merchandise and without my money.This experience feels careless and dismissive of the customer. When a company takes payment but does not ensure the customer actually receives the product—and then refuses to help—that is unacceptable.I am now forced to dispute this charge with my bank and escalate the issue further. I would caution others to be aware that if something goes wrong with delivery, Shoe Carnival may not stand behind their order

Majeedah
Was this helpful?

Great experience ,

After reading these review's, I was concerned about my order. I accidentally ordered the same pair two times. Knowing it was my fault I contacted Shoe Carnival via chat. The AI message sent me to a real person chat.It asked my phone number, three minutes later I received a call from the Manager.She told me she would send a free return label email. It was a great experience ordering and return. The separate shoe order came in 2 days.

L Hall
Was this helpful?

Great experience ,

After reading these review's, I was concerned about my order. I accidentally ordered the same pair two times. Knowing it was my fault I contacted Shoe Carnival via chat. The AI message sent me to a real person chat.It asked my phone number, three minutes later I received a call from the Manager.She told me she would send a free return label email. It was a great experience ordering and return. The separate shoe order came in 2 days.

L Hall
Was this helpful?

So far I'm getting my item the next day…

So far I'm getting my item the next day after ordering. Now take into consideration that I haven't received it yet and I don't stay far from the mall where it is coming from..I'm o.k. so far, but I might be editing this review tomorrow..we will see

Donald Hammond
Was this helpful?

So far I'm getting my item the next day…

So far I'm getting my item the next day after ordering. Now take into consideration that I haven't received it yet and I don't stay far from the mall where it is coming from..I'm o.k. so far, but I might be editing this review tomorrow..we will see

Donald Hammond
Was this helpful?

Charges for shipping that’s should have…

Charges for shipping that’s should have been 2 day delivery.product is suppose to be delivered over a week later. Not the first time this has happened. They also have the worst customer service. Very argumentative and constantly talked over you. It was there mistake not mine.

Kim
Was this helpful?

Charges for shipping that’s should have…

Charges for shipping that’s should have been 2 day delivery.product is suppose to be delivered over a week later. Not the first time this has happened. They also have the worst customer service. Very argumentative and constantly talked over you. It was there mistake not mine.

Kim
Was this helpful?

They said Doordash delivered my shoes…

They said Doordash delivered my shoes and i am livid

Nicolette Harris
Was this helpful?

They said Doordash delivered my shoes…

They said Doordash delivered my shoes and i am livid

Nicolette Harris
Was this helpful?

a scam

a scam! & there's no customer service online or via phone - everything is automated! don't waste your time

Dalia
Was this helpful?

a scam

a scam! & there's no customer service online or via phone - everything is automated! don't waste your time

Dalia
Was this helpful?

Great first time experience. I would order from them again. I ordered a pair of women’s Kamick…

I ordered a pair of women’s Kamick winter boots. I’m a size 9 wide. I needed a size bigger. They paid my return shipping and I just received my 10s today. It took about 4-5 days for my exchange to arrive. They looked great. I tried them on, perfect fit. I love them and am so glad I gave them a chance. I see a lot of bad reviews on here but my experience was great!!!

Judy Fritz
Was this helpful?

Great first time experience. I would order from them again. I ordered a pair of women’s Kamick…

I ordered a pair of women’s Kamick winter boots. I’m a size 9 wide. I needed a size bigger. They paid my return shipping and I just received my 10s today. It took about 4-5 days for my exchange to arrive. They looked great. I tried them on, perfect fit. I love them and am so glad I gave them a chance. I see a lot of bad reviews on here but my experience was great!!!

Judy Fritz
Was this helpful?

Seemless purchseing

Was happy with the checkout process and the product, 5 Stars!

Nick Dover
Was this helpful?

Seemless purchseing

Was happy with the checkout process and the product, 5 Stars!

Nick Dover
Was this helpful?

Do not EVER order from here

Do not EVER order from here. Not only do they send you used shoes but there in the wrong size. There gross and covered in something sticky. I sent them back and they sent them right back to me!!!! Im so over this company not to mention there customer service sounds like a 10 year old girl whos more worried about her nails then customers. This company needs to shut down!!!

Brittany Noel
Was this helpful?

Do not EVER order from here

Do not EVER order from here. Not only do they send you used shoes but there in the wrong size. There gross and covered in something sticky. I sent them back and they sent them right back to me!!!! Im so over this company not to mention there customer service sounds like a 10 year old girl whos more worried about her nails then customers. This company needs to shut down!!!

Brittany Noel
Was this helpful?

If I could give them 0 stars I would

If I could give them 0 stars I would , we bought the wrong size so we asked to do a return they sent the scan bar code we sent it off this s#$t company returned them back to us dont ever shop here won't give us a refund

Carter Yuson
Was this helpful?

If I could give them 0 stars I would

If I could give them 0 stars I would , we bought the wrong size so we asked to do a return they sent the scan bar code we sent it off this s#$t company returned them back to us dont ever shop here won't give us a refund

Carter Yuson
Was this helpful?
Cite this page

According to TrustPlane, Shoe Carnival has a 1.8/5 rating based on 120 verified reviews as of February 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/www-shoecarnival-com