The product is a perfect gift
The product is a perfect gift for Christmas holidays for friends. It is a small cake that is fresh and delicious! We received them quickly! Awesome traditional gift!
Jason Brooks
Was this helpful?
Tortuga Rum Cakes
4.750 reviews
Last reviewed: Mar 6, 2023Do you agree with Tortuga Rum Cakes's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 578 customers have already said.
www.tortugarumcakes.comMember since Mar 2026
Tortuga Rum Cakes is an online company. Based on 50 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed March 6, 2023.
Customer Reviews
Write a ReviewFilter:
50 reviews
Beware - Tortuga Rum Cakes May Not Deliver What You Paid For
I made an online order last December for 2 Provenance 6-Packs. I only received 1. I have called multiple times and have not been able to get a refund or get the product I paid for. Beware, customer service will not be able to help. They don't return your calls. Even though the cakes are very good, I will not buy from their online store again.
Bert
Was this helpful?
Best cakes ever
Best cakes ever. Addictive.
Mr. Lover
Was this helpful?
Very economical prices...
Very economical prices. I have ordered cakes here many times and everything is always super delicious.
Megan
Was this helpful?
The cakes are delicious and the service…
The cakes are delicious and the service is excellent. I have bought here many times and it is always top notch.
David Chapman
Was this helpful?
Definitely not REAL rum cake!!!
This cake is so bad, no rum taste a weird chemical aftertaste. All the fruit is on the outside not even mixed in right. It’s nothing like it use to be and a embarrassment to any Caribbean island selling it! People buying this must have never made a cake in their lives if they actually like it! Thank God I’m Bajan and can make the real thing or I’d be crying now, I’ve had Irish butter rum cake that tasted 100 times better than this.
Theresa Lord
Was this helpful?
The best cake
The best cake! The cakes are so moist, The best I have ever had.
Deborah Garcia
Was this helpful?
Good choice.
Good choice.Pleasant prices.I have ordered pies here many times already - everything is always super.
Emilijans Jankevics
Was this helpful?
If you want a delicious dessert
If you want a delicious dessert, be sure to come here.
Mcan
Was this helpful?
Great Cakes and Great Customer Service!
These Delicious Cakes! I have ordered Tortuga Rum Cakes for years as gifts and for myself. I recently placed a gift order and more cakes were delivered than what was ordered and paid for. I contacted customer service and within a couple of hours, I received an email from Adeanys, Customer Service Advisor. She apologized for the incorrect order and informed me that the 10 additional cakes did not need be returned. Wow! Great Customer Service and Great Cakes!
Sharon
Was this helpful?
Good
I can say that the taste of the cake really taste so good. I am writing this while eating the cake. I will order again.
Nei Morante
Was this helpful?
Excellent service.
Excellent service.
Gunnarsson
Was this helpful?
Sent it as a gift and was embarrassed at the size
So disappointed an embarrassed with the size. I bought and sent it to my son for his birthday since I can't be with him due to the stay at home order. In the meantime my daughter purchased one for herself. The cost was almost $30 for a cake that is so small it was embarrassing to send. I was shocked when I heard how small it was for that price. I entered in a date closer to his birthday of April 28 but they sent it immediately which was fine but not what I wanted. When I went to the site and saw the boxes all the cakes look much bigger. I bought the 16 oz size and was embarrassed when I heard how small it was. Thirty dollars was definitely not worth to pay for the price of that cake I don't care how good it is supposed to taste. I wouldn't buy from there again. I don't feel that size is worth the price.
Peggy Grandel Muraco
Was this helpful?
Love the Tortuga Rum Cakes!!
Love the Tortuga Rum Cakes!!! And they are delivered to my home at NY.
Irina Volos
Was this helpful?
Everything they have is devine!
Everything they have is devine!Love all of the cakes,and the chocolates.
KAY JERNIGAN
Was this helpful?
Absolutely delish
Absolutely delish! Will continue to purchase
jean montgomery della rocco
Was this helpful?
Best Rum Cakes
I have enjoyed these Rum cakes for years! I send them to all my relatives for the holidays!
Cliff Satterwhite
Was this helpful?
amazing love it
amazing love it
yvonne
Was this helpful?
easy to use and order from.
easy to use and order from.
JEFFREY JOHNSON
Was this helpful?
Best Rum cake I have ever had
Best Rum cake I have ever had
BARBARA L
Was this helpful?
Cite this page
According to TrustPlane, Tortuga Rum Cakes has a 4.7/5 rating based on 50 verified reviews as of April 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/www-tortugarumcakes-com