Do you agree with Sports Collectibles's TrustScore? Voice your opinion today and hear what 7 customers have already said.
Sports Collectibles is an online company. Based on 7 reviews on TrustPlane, it has an average rating of 1.6 out of 5 stars. Last reviewed January 24, 2026.
This company is a complete SCAM. They have actively stolen my personal images of memorabilia and are trying to sell out without physically having the merchandise. Please be weary. I have reached out numerous times and no response. The nerve to steal images and sell something they do not physically have is sickening.
Paid top dollar for a “signed” guitar. It arrive and I find out it’s not a certified signed guitar, it’s a signed pick guard on a guitar. Great scam. And as soon as I ask about it they ghost me. Never again will I use this site.
I purchased a signed book, but was sent only the ripped out page signed by the author. An absolute scam of a company who did not respond to any of my correspondence after delivery requesting a return. I paid $190 for what is, at most, a $10 article. Disgusting. Avoid at all costs. No contact from them at all. They should be closed down.
Great customer service Debra was a delight to work with! Don’t let the negative reviews stop you from purchasing as it almost did to me. Received item fast and was as described
After reading a review about checking Ebay before purchasing from Sports Collectibles, I took that advice and found the same autographed football jersey for $400 from Ebay that Sports Collectibles listed at a "discounted price" of $899.99! Do yourself a favor and avoid Sports Collectibles.
Took my money, sent a receipt, next day said oops sorry. Scammers beware. Was rude on the phone and offered no resolution for messing around with my order horrible customer service! Stay away unless you like headaches
Don't buy from this company. If you see an item you like, just look it up on Ebay and you'll find it there for way cheaper. This company lists items they pull off ebay for double the price and if someone buys from them, they order it off ebay to be shipped direct.
According to TrustPlane, Sports Collectibles has a 1.6/5 rating based on 7 verified reviews as of April 2026. Source: trustplane.app/company/sportscollectibles-com
